Skip to content

Industry Perspective

How to run a small AI work pilot you can actually evaluate

Choose one checkable task, protect the inputs and count the time spent verifying the result. A small AI pilot should produce evidence about your workflow.

Two colleagues compare a screen with printed reference material.

An AI tool can produce a convincing draft before you have decided what a good result looks like. That makes a small workplace trial easy to start and difficult to judge. The useful question is specific: can this tool help with one recurring task while preserving the accuracy, confidentiality and judgment that task requires?

Research offers reasons to test carefully. An MIT study published in 2023 found productivity improvements on selected professional writing tasks. Harvard Business School’s account of a separate consulting experiment described an uneven technological frontier: usefulness varied between tasks. Neither finding establishes that a particular tool will improve your workflow today. A trial should generate evidence about your work.

Choose a task you can check

Begin with a bounded activity whose inputs and correct output are accessible. Turning an approved public document into a draft internal briefing is easier to evaluate than asking a tool to discover an unfamiliar market and recommend a strategy. In the first case, a reviewer can compare every material claim with the supplied document.

Write down the intended audience, required facts, acceptable length and prohibited additions before opening the tool. Define a serious error in advance. For a briefing, that might be an invented deadline, a missing qualification or a recommendation presented as an established fact. A polished tone should never compensate for one of those failures.

Select several representative examples, including an awkward one with conflicting information or an important exception. Keep an example of the usual human process as a comparison. This is a learning exercise, so a handful of cases can reveal problems; it cannot establish a reliable organization-wide success rate.

Set the information boundary first

NIST’s Generative AI Profile identifies risks including confabulation and data privacy. Confabulation is the production of plausible but false content. Privacy questions concern what enters the system as well as what appears in its response. Those are separate checks, and a good answer does not prove the input was appropriate to share.

Use an approved tool and follow your organization’s information rules. For an initial trial, choose public or purpose-created material. Do not assume that removing a person’s name makes a client file safe: combinations of dates, roles and events may still identify someone. Confirm permitted data, retention, access and provider terms with the responsible person before using real confidential work.

Keep consequential decisions outside the trial. A tool that helps organize information has not thereby earned authority to decide hiring outcomes, approve payments or provide specialist advice. Name the human who remains responsible for the finished work and the person who can stop the experiment.

Measure the whole workflow

Record time for preparation, prompting, reading, checking and correction. Comparing only drafting time can hide a longer review process. Also record whether the reviewer needed unfamiliar expertise or had to reopen sources repeatedly to resolve confident claims.

  • Accuracy: Which statements were unsupported, wrong or incomplete?
  • Usefulness: Did the result answer the actual brief?
  • Review effort: How much work was needed before acceptance?
  • Consistency: Did similar inputs produce comparably usable results?

Where practical, ask a colleague to judge completed outputs against the same rubric without being told which process produced them. That will not remove every bias, but it can make the discussion more concrete than a preference for whichever draft looks most fluent.

Make verification an observable step

Require the reviewer to check names, figures, dates, quotations and conclusions against the approved source material. A citation suggested by the tool is a lead to inspect. Repeating a question or asking the model whether it is certain does not independently verify the answer.

For the public-document briefing, keep a simple claim checklist beside the draft. Mark each important statement as supported, corrected or removed. Then check what the draft omitted. Accurate individual sentences can still create a misleading overall picture if a limitation disappears.

Finish with a narrow decision: continue for this task under these conditions, revise the process, or stop. Record the tool, date, task and review requirements so future users understand the boundary. Recheck after material changes. A useful pilot earns a defined place in a workflow through observed results and manageable review effort.

More to read

Browse insights