Skip to content

Professional Development

Check an unfamiliar journal before submitting your research

An invitation, polished website or rapid turnaround promise is not enough to choose a journal. Verify its identity, editorial process and terms before sharing a manuscript.

A woman compares two open journals at a library table.

An email inviting your professional research can arrive at an appealing moment: the manuscript is nearly ready and the journal promises a quick decision. Before uploading it, check whether the outlet reaches the right readers and offers a credible, clearly described publication process.

Begin with evidence rather than a verdict based on appearance. A new or unfamiliar journal is not automatically unreliable. An established-looking website is not proof of sound practice. Your task is to verify the specific outlet, its claims and the terms that would apply to your work.

Confirm the journal’s identity and fit

Find the journal independently rather than relying only on the invitation’s link. Check its exact title, publisher and official website. Where it claims affiliation with a scholarly society, institution or directory, verify that relationship at the other organization’s own site.

The fifth edition of the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, published by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME on 29 October 2026, explicitly addresses misleading identities and copied or hijacked journal websites. Its updated framework gives authors a current basis for asking what a journal discloses about itself.

Read several recent papers and the aims and scope. Does the journal publish the kind of work you have written, for readers you want to reach? A broad invitation praising your expertise tells you less about fit than actual editorial content and submission requirements.

Look for an accountable editorial process

Identify the editors, their affiliations and the editorial office’s contact details. Check that the journal explains who makes decisions, which content receives peer review and how that review works. A claimed turnaround time should describe a process rather than imply that acceptance is already assured.

If a listed editor or affiliation seems doubtful, verify it through an independent institutional source or ask your librarian for help. Avoid treating a person’s name on a website as confirmation that they have agreed to serve.

Shamseer and colleagues’ 2017 cross-sectional study compared characteristics of potential predatory and presumed legitimate biomedical journals. It examined issues including editorial information, peer-review descriptions, scope and website integrity. Its dated, discipline-specific findings support checking multiple features; they do not provide a universal test for every journal today.

For example, a manuscript about a workplace training evaluation might receive an invitation from a journal whose recent papers cover unrelated subjects and whose review process is unexplained. That combination warrants further investigation even if the invitation contains a recognizable logo.

Read the terms before the upload

Locate author charges, when they become payable and any waiver arrangements. Check copyright, licensing, repository policies and how the journal preserves published material if its website closes. Confirm any requirements from your employer, institution or funder separately.

Publication fees are used by legitimate journals as well as questionable ones. A fee alone does not establish reliability or misconduct. The useful questions concern transparency, editorial independence and what publishing services are actually provided.

Look for policies covering corrections, complaints, conflicts of interest and research ethics. The October 2026 principles also address disclosure of AI use in authorship, editorial work and peer review. Check the journal’s actual instructions, because your obligations depend on its policies and the requirements governing your research.

Record unresolved questions and get another view

Cukier and colleagues’ 2020 systematic review of checklists for detecting potential predatory biomedical journals found no optimal checklist among those assessed. That finding argues against treating a short tick-box exercise as a definitive label. Use your review to identify evidence and gaps, then seek specialist advice where needed.

  • Verified: Which identity, editorial and publication claims have independent support?
  • Unclear: Which policies, charges or contacts remain unexplained?
  • Relevant: Does the readership and article type fit your work?
  • Next step: Submit, request clarification or choose another outlet?

Ask a research librarian, experienced coauthor or institutional research office to review material concerns. Keep dated notes and copies of the terms you checked. If important claims remain contradictory or unverifiable, pause the submission. A credible destination should allow you to understand where your research will appear, how it will be assessed and what you are agreeing to before you hand it over.

More to read

Browse insights